Best Carbon Arrows (Reviews 2018 & Comparison)

Well, choosing the best carbon arrows isn’t as easy as you may think. Every arrow is different and comes with its own perks. And you have to consider some basic factors before going ahead and spending a great amount of deal on them.

That's why I've put together a list of features you need for evaluating any carbon arrows, as well as some visualized charts basing on my rating below. But before that, check this out:

Best Carbon Arrows for the Money:

1. ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrow

2. GPP Archery Carbon Targeting/Hunting Arrows

3. Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

(Editor's choice)

4. Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows

5. Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows​

Best Carbon Arrows - Rating Chart

Top Rated Carbon Arrows - Rating Chart

What Features to Consider?

1. Spine

Spine rating is usually the measurement of an arrows stiffness. If an arrow doesn’t have the perfect balance of stiffness, then it becomes less efficient in hitting the target.

Why Spine Ratings Matter ?

When someone shoots an arrow, throughout the whole cycle, a vast amount of energy transfers to the arrow from the bow. It creates enough force to make the arrow oscillate and flex.

If the arrow oscillates too much, then it won’t hit the target or have a hard time going straight. On the other hand, if it doesn’t oscillate at all, then it won’t be able to clear the bow.

The great carbon arrows would have the perfect balance of flex, giving it the necessary stiffness for flying straight. Usually, too stiff arrows would result in going left and too weak arrows tend to go right side.

Moreover, a weaker hunting arrow will have a spine rating of 500 and the perfect arrow should have a rating very close to 300. A rating of 300 would mean that it’s much stiffer than a rating of 500.

On the other hand, the stiffness seems to increase with the weight. That's why a heavier arrow will be more prone to be stiff.

Spine Comparison Chart

Arrow Performances:

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrow
ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon 30-Inch 7.8mm Shaft Removable Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips for Recuve & Compound Bow( Pack of 12)

Via Amazon.com

While shooting with this type of arrows you will get a spine rating of 500. According to the rating, it’s not good to have such a high value as it makes it weaker. A better and stiffer arrow will have less spine if you want a smoother shooting. (Score: 3/5)

GPP Archery Carbon Targeting/Hunting Arrows

GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Targeting / Hunting Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips (12 Pack) for Recuve Bow & Compound Bow

Via Amazon.com

With 400 spine rating, GPP Archery Carbon Arrows scores higher than ANTSIR Outdoors Shaft Removable Carbon Arrows. Still, the arrows should have much less spine to be stiffer arrows. Accordingly, they are good but not good enough. (Score: 3/5)

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes

Via Amazon.com

This Maxima arrows have around 250-350 spine rate. With this spine rate, they are far better than other carbon arrows. I can easily say that they are stiffer and hunters would like to use such kind of arrows. They are one of the best carbon arrows for compound bow. (Score: 4.5/5)

Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows

 Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt with 4-Inch Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

350 spine rate makes these arrows closer to being stiff. Hunters will also choose these arrows for their less spine rate. At least they are close enough. (Score: 4.5/5)

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows

 Huntingdoor 30

Via Amazon.com

The Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows have spine rate of around 550-650. With this spine rate, you can’t expect a good performance. (Score: 2.5/5)


2. Arrow Weight​/Grain

While choosing the best carbon arrow, you need to take a good look at the weight. It’s really an important feature. Typically the weight of an arrow is measured in grains per inch (GPI) or grains. This measurement includes different factors such as:

  • The arrow diameter: Depends on the width of the arrow.
  • The thickness of the arrow walls: Normally every arrow is hollow inside, but the wall thickness seems to vary from arrow to arrow. This thickness has a great influence on the overall weight of the arrow.
  • Arrow material: Arrows are mainly made of three material: wood, carbon and aluminum. Some arrows are made of carbon-aluminum combo. This material puts a great impact on the weight.

You should always choose an arrow that is directly linked to your bow. In general cases, lighter arrows are used in lighter bows and heavier arrows are used for heavy bows.

Hunters typically favor heavier arrows instead of lighter ones as they tend to have the more kinetic energy to go a long distance and strike hard. Lighter arrows are more suitable for archery practice or tournament. It tends to be faster than heavy ones as, heavier arrows preserve more kinetic energy, making it slower.

If you are starting off as a beginner. First of all, you should start shooting with the same weight and later switch heavier and lighter weight. Anyways, a perfect arrow would be between 200 to 500 grains. Best for both target practice and hunting.

Weight Comparison Chart

Arrow Performances:

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrow
ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon 30-Inch 7.8mm Shaft Removable Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips for Recuve & Compound Bow( Pack of 12)

Via Amazon.com

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon arrows have weighs 432 grains. A great hunting arrow for that can also be used in archery. Typically great for hunting small animals like turkey or elk. (Score: 4/5)

GPP Archery Carbon Targeting / Hunting Arrows
GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Targeting / Hunting Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips (12 Pack) for Recuve Bow & Compound Bow

Via Amazon.com

A bit heavier than ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon arrows weighing at 552 grains can be your next best choice for outdoor activities. Best suited for hunting rather than target practicing. (Score: 3.5/5)

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows
Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes

Via Amazon.com

Carbon Express Maxima did it again. Weighing at just 286 grains, they reek perfection. These babies are the perfect arrow for any situation. Hunting or archery, whatever your choice, these will never let you down. Although lightweight arrows make it more suitable for archery. (Score: 5/5)

Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows
 Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt with 4-Inch Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

Another best carbon crossbow bolts from Carbon Express. PileDriver is a bit heavier than Maxima with 442 grains in total. You can use it in any situation. (Score: 4/5)

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows
 Huntingdoor 30

Via Amazon.com

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon arrows are the heaviest on the list. They weigh 556 grains. Just like their name these are the best arrows for target shooting. A great arrow with deep penetration that goes a long way. (Score: 3.5/5)

Editor's Choice:

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com


3. Diameter

It’s another important feature of an arrow that you should definitely consider before buying one. Arrows come with a wide range of diameters and used for different situations:

Thinner Arrows for Hunting

Hunters mainly prefer thinner ones instead of thick one. The thin ones are less affected by wind so that makes it a perfect choice for hunting. Also, thinner arrows have better penetration depth than thicker ones.

Thicker Arrows for Archery

If you are looking for arrows more suitable for archery then you should always go for thicker ones. An arrow with thicker diameter will be more prone to link through the outlines on the target, giving you a perfect score.

Thicker ones are also used for a 3D archery sessions where people usually shot at animal replicas rather than round ones. Arrow diameter plays a vital role in archery competitions. A specific diameter is allowed only and using above that range can disqualify you.

Diameter Comparison Chart 2

Arrow Performances:

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrows
ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon 30-Inch 7.8mm Shaft Removable Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips for Recuve & Compound Bow( Pack of 12)

Via Amazon.com

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon arrows are considered to be on the thinner list. Although they are not micro arrows but still best for hunting. With a diameter of .309", they are one of the best carbon hunting arrows as they are less affected by wind. (Score: 4/5)

GPP Archery Carbon Targeting / Hunting Arrows
GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Targeting / Hunting Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips (12 Pack) for Recuve Bow & Compound Bow

Via Amazon.com

Same as ANTSIR Outdoors, GPP Archery Carbon arrows have the exact same diameter of .309”. Needless to say, they are best suited for hunting rather than archery. Another great set of carbon arrows. (Score: 4/5)

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows
Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes

Via Amazon.com

Carbon Express Maxima RED seems to beat them all in being the thinnest. With a diameter of only .300”, they surely are close to being micro diameter arrows. Hunters seem to prefer Carbon RED over other as it has lesser friction then them. (Score: 5/5)

Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows
 Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt with 4-Inch Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

A bit thicker arrow set, Carbon Express PileDriver has a diameter of .348". Thicker arrows mean more friction and suitable for archery rather than hunting. Although there are some hunters that use PileDriver for hunting elks and deer. (Score: 2.5/5)

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows
 Huntingdoor 30

Via Amazon.com

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon arrows are slightly thicker than Carbon Express Maxima, GPP Archery Carbon, and ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon arrows. Their diameter is .31”. Suitable for hunting but not efficient as other on the list. (Score: 3.5/5)


4. Length

The length of the arrow must be perfect. It actually depends on few factors such as the type of the bow, the position of the arrow rest and the draw length of the bow.

Why is this important?

Too short arrows compared to the bow can be very dangerous for you. Even if the arrow just fits the bow, still it’s not perfect. On the other hand, if the length is too large, it might become a problem to handle the whole set up. Arrows a little bit larger than the bow would be better, even perfect.

The arrow should sit at least 1" beyond the arrow rest when the bow is at full draw, that is the perfect arrow length. A too short arrow can lodge behind the arrow rest at full draw and the arrow could collapse and crack upon release.

You need to know the measurement of the draw length of the bow. It is not necessary at all to match the bow draw length to the arrow length, though people may think so.

When the bow is at full draw the distance between the grooves of the nock to a position 1.75” beyond the grip pivot point is the length of the draw of the bow. Or simply, we can say that when the bow is drawn back the distance from the nock point to the front of the riser is the draw length.

So, it is okay on maximum setups if the arrow is slightly shorter than the adjusted draw length of the bow.

Length Comparison Chart

Arrow Performances:

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrows
ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon 30-Inch 7.8mm Shaft Removable Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips for Recuve & Compound Bow( Pack of 12)

Via Amazon.com

ANTSIR Outdoors Arrows are of 30" in length. 30” length arrows are good for teenagers or adults but not for the kids. But it is not too short. As you already know it, if the arrow is not too short then you can use it in any kind of bow setup. (Score: 4/5)

GPP Archery Carbon Targeting / Hunting Arrows
GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Targeting / Hunting Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips (12 Pack) for Recuve Bow & Compound Bow

Via Amazon.com

These arrows are 30“long in total. They also have a good length and so, we can choose any type of bows to use them without any problems. Thus, we can say that according to the length, they are equal to ANTSIR Outdoor Carbon Arrows. (Score: 4/5)

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows
Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes

Via Amazon.com

31.5“, it is certainly a great length for arrows. Hunters would love to choose this type of arrows with their closed eyes as we are only talking about length now. The longer the arrows are, the better they are. Even, you can resize it by cutting them off if it is necessary. (Score: 5/5)

Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows
 Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt with 4-Inch Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

The Pile Driver Fletched Carbon Arrows are shorter. They are only of 20“length. Yes, this is far shorter than the other arrows. Hunter or archer must need specific kind of bow setup for these arrows. Otherwise, they will face problems while shooting. Even, it is also possible that they might not be able to fit it in the arrow rest. (Score: 2/5)

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows
 Huntingdoor 30

Via Amazon.com

The Huntingdoor Carbon Target Arrows also have a good length of 31“. They are also good enough for shooting as we can fit them any type of arrow rest. They are better ANTSIR, GPP and of course Pile Driver carbon arrows. (Score: 5/5)


5. Straightness

Straightness is the second most important category. When there were no carbon arrows straightness was the biggest area to think about. But with the whole carbon arrows, straightness is not a fact to fear. Still, straightness is important.

When you launch an arrow a frequency vibration occurs there. This frequency will be literally consistent and the shooting will be great with a straight arrow. But the frequency would change when we bend the arrow, so the oscillation.

Though you cannot bend a whole carbon arrow, straightness still matters to choose the top rated carbon arrows. It is quite possible that the carbon arrow may not be a pure carbon arrow.

Straightness of an arrow is divided into few classes.

  • Standard-grade carbon arrows have a straightness of +/-.005-.006". These shafts are especially for the beginning archers and the hunters. These arrows are more than enough for the big hunting game.
  • A basic carbon shaft with +/-.006" straightness is straighter enough to use with any kind of bow setup.
  • Mid-grade shafts with the straightness of around +/-.003-.004" are better than the standard-grade arrows.

If we want to have the best ever arrows, there are also pro-grade arrows of +/-.001-.002" straightness.

Arrow straightness undoubtedly does matter. It will be best if we use the arrow of higher straightness for hunting or an archery game. Less straightness can cause any kind of damage while shooting.

Straightness Comparison Chart

Arrow Performances:

ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon Shaft Removable Arrows
ANTSIR Outdoors Carbon 30-Inch 7.8mm Shaft Removable Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips for Recuve & Compound Bow( Pack of 12)

Via Amazon.com

ANTSIR Outdoors Arrows have +/-.006” of straightness. Well, I think you already know that the arrows having such straightness are very basic. That means they will give worse performances than other arrows. Though knowing that pure carbon arrows cannot be bent, still there are chances for arrows to bend if they are not completely made of carbons. (Score: 2/5)

GPP Archery Carbon Targeting / Hunting Arrows
GPP Archery Carbon 30-Inch Targeting / Hunting Arrows with Field Points Replaceable Tips (12 Pack) for Recuve Bow & Compound Bow

Via Amazon.com

GPP Archery Carbon Arrows contain straightness of +/-.006“. They are also like basic arrows with poor performance. So, if we compare them in the sense of straightness, they are equal to ANTSIR Outdoor Carbon Arrows. The best carbon arrows should have better straightness and they don’t have a good rating in this case. (Score: 2/5)

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows
Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes

Via Amazon.com

These arrows have +/- .0025“straightness. According to straightness, hunters choose this type of arrows if they have no problem with its price. Let’s categorize them into the pro-grade arrows or top carbon arrows as mentioned before. They have a high rating for their better straightness. (Score: 5/5)

Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt Arrows
 Carbon Express PileDriver Fletched Carbon Crossbolt with 4-Inch Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

The Pile Driver Fletched Carbon Arrows have a straightness of +/- .004“. Well, I can say that at least, they are better than the first two kinds of arrows you just read about above. So, I am going to classify them and put them with the mid-grade arrows. (Score: 3/5)

Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target Arrows
 Huntingdoor 30

Via Amazon.com

The Huntingdoor Archery Carbon Target arrows are also got the place in the standard-grade or you can say in the basic arrow grade with the straightness of +/- .006“. (Score: 2/5)


The Bottom Line?

Evaluating all the performance from all of the categories, Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows gets the crown. With a splendid score of 24/25, sure it is the best carbon arrows from the list. Suitable for any situation if you ask me.

Editor's Choice:

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows

Carbon Express Maxima RED Fletched Carbon Arrows with Dynamic Spine Control and Blazer Vanes, 6-Pack

Via Amazon.com

I really hope you enjoyed reading the article. I’ve compiled every detail for helping you decide the right one and I’m sure you won’t have any confusion anymore. Comment below and let me know what you think and don’t forget to share it!

Robert Gate

I was enthusiastic about Hunting from the first shot. From then I decided to become a pro hunter. If you find something helpful in my blog, I would be proud of.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below